Skip to Content

Claim and Evidence Notes Worksheet

Claim and Evidence Notes Worksheet

About This Worksheet

This Grade 5 listening and speaking worksheet helps students listen to an opinion speech and identify the speaker’s claim, reasons, and evidence. The topic focuses on whether students should learn cursive writing in school.

This is a valuable skill because students need to understand not only what someone believes, but also why they believe it and what evidence they use to support the argument.

Learning Goals

The main goal is to help students break spoken arguments into clear parts.

Students practice identifying the speaker’s claim, listening for supporting reasons, and matching evidence to each reason.

They also reflect on whether they agree or disagree with the speaker and explain their own thinking in one sentence.

What Students Will Do

Students listen as the teacher reads an opinion speech aloud.

First, they write the speaker’s main claim about cursive instruction.

Next, they record up to three reasons the speaker gives. For each reason, they also write the example, fact, or evidence that supports it.

At the bottom, students decide whether they agree or disagree with the speaker’s claim and give a brief explanation.

Common Challenges

Some students may confuse a reason with evidence.

A simple way to explain the difference is: a reason tells why the speaker believes something, while evidence gives an example, fact, or detail that supports that reason.

Others may focus too much on their own opinion and miss what the speaker actually said.

Teaching Suggestions

Teachers can model the difference between claim, reason, and evidence before reading the speech.

A useful sentence frame is, “The speaker believes ___ because ___.”

For stronger students, ask them to judge which reason is strongest and explain why.

Worksheet Features

The page includes a claim box, three reason-and-evidence sections, and a short reflection prompt.

This worksheet works well for argument listening, debate preparation, speaking lessons, or opinion-writing support.